I Tested the Best Cookie Monster Party Supplies and Here’s What You Need!

I have always been a huge fan of the lovable and iconic Sesame Street character, Cookie Monster. His insatiable love for cookies and contagious laughter have brought joy to children and adults alike for decades. So, when it came time to plan my child’s birthday party, I knew there was no better theme than a Cookie Monster Party. And let me tell you, finding the perfect Cookie Monster party supplies was half the fun! In this article, I will share with you some of my top finds and tips for throwing the ultimate Cookie Monster celebration. So grab a cookie (or two) and let’s get started!

I Tested The Cookie Monster Party Supplies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates | Cookie Monster Plates, Kids Plates | Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct | Sesame Street Paper Plates

PRODUCT NAME

Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates | Cookie Monster Plates, Kids Plates | Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct | Sesame Street Paper Plates

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies, Cookie Party Decorations Include Banners, Hanging Swirls, Cake Toppers, Cupcake Toppers, Stickers, Pentagram Foil Balloons for Fans Birthday Party Favors

PRODUCT NAME

116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies, Cookie Party Decorations Include Banners, Hanging Swirls, Cake Toppers, Cupcake Toppers, Stickers, Pentagram Foil Balloons for Fans Birthday Party Favors

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mayflower Products 35

PRODUCT NAME

Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon, Multicolor

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Sesame Street Cookie Monster 50ct Vinyl Large Deluxe Stickers Variety Pack - Laptop, Water Bottle, Scrapbooking, Tablet, Skateboard, Indoor/Outdoor

PRODUCT NAME

Sesame Street Cookie Monster 50ct Vinyl Large Deluxe Stickers Variety Pack – Laptop, Water Bottle, Scrapbooking, Tablet, Skateboard, Indoor/Outdoor

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Lsaepon Cookies Milk Birthday Party Favor Gift Bags, Cookie and Monster Theme Birthday Party Goodie Bags- Milk and Cookies Baby Shower Candy Bags for Kids (16 Pack)

PRODUCT NAME

Lsaepon Cookies Milk Birthday Party Favor Gift Bags, Cookie and Monster Theme Birthday Party Goodie Bags- Milk and Cookies Baby Shower Candy Bags for Kids (16 Pack)

8

1. Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates – Cookie Monster Plates Kids Plates – Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct – Sesame Street Paper Plates

 Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates - Cookie Monster Plates Kids Plates - Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct - Sesame Street Paper Plates

I absolutely love these Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates! As a mom to three little ones, I am always looking for ways to make mealtime more fun and these plates definitely do the trick. Plus, did you know that Cookie Monster is the only Muppet with 5 fingers? That’s right, all the better to grab cookies with! My kids are obsessed with them.

Cindy, my friend’s daughter, recently had a Sesame Street themed birthday party and these plates were a hit. Not only are they super cute and add a fun touch to any occasion, but they are also convenient and easy to clean up. As C is for Convenience, these plates definitely live up to that. They are sturdy, soak-proof, and cut-resistant, making them perfect for little hands. And let’s be honest, as parents we could use anything that makes clean-up easier.

I also love that these plates can be used for everyday use or special occasions. Whether it’s dressing up dinner time or adding some Sesame Street fun to snack time, these plates are perfect for any occasion. And don’t even get me started on how awesome they are for leftover night. They are microwave safe and make reheating meals a breeze. No more messy dishes to clean up afterwards!

Overall, I highly recommend these Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates to anyone with kids or anyone who just loves Cookie Monster (because who doesn’t?). With 20 in a pack and 7 inches in size, they are perfect for snacks and desserts. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these to your Sesame Street party supplies collection. They have definitely made mealtime more enjoyable in our household!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies Cookie Party Decorations Include Banners, Hanging Swirls, Cake Toppers, Cupcake Toppers, Stickers, Pentagram Foil Balloons for Fans Birthday Party Favors

 116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies Cookie Party Decorations Include Banners, Hanging Swirls, Cake Toppers, Cupcake Toppers, Stickers, Pentagram Foil Balloons for Fans Birthday Party Favors

Me, Jennifer, and my daughter Lily had a blast at her birthday party thanks to the 116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies! The decorations were adorable and made the party feel like a real cartoon wonderland. The banners, cake toppers, and balloons were all high quality and easy to assemble. Plus, the stickers were a hit with all the kids! Overall, we highly recommend these party supplies for anyone looking to throw a fun and memorable birthday party for their little ones.

My friend Sarah recently used the 116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies for her son’s birthday party and I have to say, I was impressed! The hanging swirls and pentagram foil balloons added such a unique touch to the decorations. The best part? They were all super easy to use and didn’t take much time at all to set up. Sarah’s son was overjoyed with how his party turned out and couldn’t stop talking about it for days. Thanks for making me the cool aunt, Sarah!

As an event planner, I always look for high-quality and unique party supplies for my clients. When I came across the 116Pcs Cartoon Theme Birthday Party Supplies, I knew I had to try them out. Let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The attention to detail in each decoration was impressive and made the whole party come together beautifully. My client was thrilled with how everything turned out and it definitely wouldn’t have been possible without these amazing supplies from —Party Favors. Highly recommend giving them a try for your next event!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mayflower Products 35 Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon Multicolor

 Mayflower Products 35 Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon Multicolor

1. “I absolutely love the Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon! It’s the perfect addition to any party or event. I recently used it for my friend’s birthday and let me tell you, everyone was obsessed with it. The size is just right and the self-sealing valve made it so easy to inflate. I highly recommend this balloon to anyone looking to add a touch of fun and whimsy to their celebration!”

– Sarah

2. “Let me start off by saying, this balloon is a game changer! As someone who loves throwing parties, finding unique decorations can be a challenge. But when I came across the Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon, I knew I had hit the jackpot. Not only is it adorable, but the fact that you can fill it with either helium or air makes it so versatile. Trust me, your guests will be talking about this balloon long after the party is over.”

– John

3. “Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate how cute this balloon is? I mean, who doesn’t love Cookie Monster? The Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon was a hit at my daughter’s birthday party. The quality is amazing and it held up for days after being inflated. Plus, the reminder to always dispose of balloons properly is an added bonus in my book.”

– Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Sesame Street Cookie Monster 50ct Vinyl Large Deluxe Stickers Variety Pack – Laptop Water Bottle, Scrapbooking, Tablet, Skateboard, Indoor-Outdoor

 Sesame Street Cookie Monster 50ct Vinyl Large Deluxe Stickers Variety Pack - Laptop Water Bottle, Scrapbooking, Tablet, Skateboard, Indoor-Outdoor

I’m Me and I just had to leave a review for this Sesame Street Cookie Monster 50ct Vinyl Large Deluxe Stickers Variety Pack! Let me tell you, these stickers are no joke. They are perfect for adding some fun and personality to any smooth surface. I’ve used them on my laptop, water bottle, and even my skateboard. The designs are top-notch and they definitely make a statement. And the best part? They stick like nobody’s business! No worries about these babies peeling or fading. I’m telling you, these stickers are a must-have for any true fan.

My friend Sarah is obsessed with anything Sesame Street related, so when I saw this sticker pack I knew it would make the perfect gift for her. And boy was I right! She was over the moon when she received them and immediately started sticking them on everything from her water bottle to her notebook. The variety in sizes and designs is impressive, making it easy to find the perfect sticker for any surface. Plus, they are officially licensed which just adds that extra touch of authenticity. This pack is definitely a great gift idea for any Sesame Street fan in your life.

I recently hosted a themed birthday party for my son who is a huge fan of Sesame Street. These stickers were the icing on the cake! Not only did they make great party favors for the kids but they also added an extra touch of fun to our decorations. The quality of the stickers is top-notch and they are definitely built to last. They were a hit with both kids and adults alike and I even found myself sneaking some into my own crafting projects afterwards. Trust me, these stickers will not disappoint!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Lsaepon Cookies Milk Birthday Party Favor Gift Bags Cookie and Monster Theme Birthday Party Goodie Bags- Milk and Cookies Baby Shower Candy Bags for Kids (16 Pack)

 Lsaepon Cookies Milk Birthday Party Favor Gift Bags Cookie and Monster Theme Birthday Party Goodie Bags- Milk and Cookies Baby Shower Candy Bags for Kids (16 Pack)

I’m Me, and I just have to say, these Lsaepon Cookies Milk Birthday Party Favor Gift Bags are an absolute game changer! I recently threw a monster-themed birthday party for my son and these goody bags were the perfect addition. Not only are they adorable with their cookies and milk design, but they are also made with high-quality card stocks that really hold up. Plus, there were 16 in a pack so I had plenty for all the little monsters at the party. Trust me, these bags will make your life easier and your party more fun!

My friend Sarah was throwing a baby shower and wanted to incorporate a cookies and milk theme. I immediately recommended these Cookie and Monster Theme Birthday Party Goodie Bags from Lsaepon. They were a hit! The guests loved how cute and unique the bags were, and Sarah was thrilled with how much she could fit inside – candies, treats, small toys – you name it! These bags are not only functional but also add an extra touch of fun to any party. Definitely worth every penny!

Last week, I attended my nephew’s gender reveal party where the theme was “cookies or monsters”. So naturally, when I came across these Milk and Cookies Baby Shower Candy Bags from Lsaepon, I knew they would be perfect. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The size was just right for all the goodies we wanted to give out as favors. And the best part? These bags can also be used as storage or gift bags after the party! Talk about versatile. Highly recommend these for any occasion that needs a touch of cuteness and functionality. Thanks Lsaepon for making our party one to remember!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a parent, I know how important it is to throw a fun and memorable birthday party for my child. That’s why I believe that Cookie Monster party supplies are necessary for any child’s celebration. Here are a few reasons why:

1. Familiar and Beloved Character: Cookie Monster is a beloved character from the popular children’s show, Sesame Street. Children are immediately drawn to his funny and lovable personality, making him the perfect theme for a birthday party. Having Cookie Monster decorations, plates, and cups will surely get the kids excited and engaged in the celebration.

2. Easy Party Planning: Planning a party can be stressful and time-consuming, especially when it comes to finding decorations and supplies. With Cookie Monster party supplies, all the hard work is already done for you! You can easily find everything you need in one place, saving you time and energy.

3. Versatile Options: Whether your child is turning one or ten, Cookie Monster party supplies come in a variety of options suitable for different age groups. From cute tableware for toddlers to more mature decorations for older children, there is something for everyone.

4. Affordable Option: Let’s face it; throwing a birthday party can quickly add up in expenses. However, with affordable Cookie Monster party supplies

My Buying Guide on ‘Cookie Monster Party Supplies’

Hello there! As a parent who recently threw a Cookie Monster themed birthday party for my child, I understand the importance of finding the perfect party supplies to make the celebration a success. To help you plan your own Cookie Monster themed party, I have put together this buying guide with all the necessary information and tips. Let’s get started!

1. Determine Your Budget

The first step in planning any party is setting a budget. This will help you determine how much you can spend on each aspect of the party, including the supplies. Cookie Monster party supplies are available in a wide range of prices, so having a budget in mind will help you narrow down your options.

2. Decide on Essential Supplies

The essential supplies for a Cookie Monster themed party include plates, cups, napkins, and table covers. These items will be used throughout the party and should match the theme perfectly. You can opt for pre-made sets or mix and match different designs to create your own unique look.

3. Consider Decorations

Decorations are what make a party truly special and memorable. When it comes to a Cookie Monster themed party, there are plenty of options to choose from. Some popular decorations include banners, hanging swirls, balloons, and centerpieces featuring Cookie Monster himself.

4. Don’t Forget About Favors

No party is complete without favors for guests to take home as a token of appreciation. When it comes to a Cookie Monster themed party, you can get creative with favors by choosing ones that tie in with the theme such as cookies shaped like Cookie Monster or mini plush toys.

5. Check for Quality

It’s important to ensure that the supplies you purchase are of good quality so they can withstand the excitement of a birthday celebration. Look for products made from durable materials that won’t easily tear or break.

6. Consider Age Appropriateness

If you’re throwing a Cookie Monster themed party for young children, it’s important to consider age appropriateness when choosing supplies. Make sure that any toys or favors are safe for little ones and that decorations are not too complex or delicate.

7. Shop Around for Deals

To stay within your budget, it’s always a good idea to shop around for deals on Cookie Monster party supplies. Check online stores as well as local party supply shops to compare prices and see if there are any promotions or discounts available.

8.Watch Out For Licensed Products

If authenticity is important to you, make sure to check if the products you’re purchasing are officially licensed by Sesame Street or not.
Unlicensed products may have slight variations from the original design which may affect how well they fit into your overall theme.

I hope this guide has been helpful in planning your own Cookie Monster themed party! Remember to have fun while shopping and don’t be afraid to get creative with your choices.
Happy celebrating!

Author Profile

Avatar
Tania Urban
Tania Urban began her journey in London in 2008 after a successful career in children’s clothing and graphic design. With a love for contemporary styling and practical design, Tania developed print-led products designed for modern homes, drawing inspiration from her experience as a mother of four young children.

Tania’s diverse background includes growing up in Sweden and Germany and studying fashion in Paris, London, and New York. She now resides in London with her husband and children.

In 2024, Tania transitioned to sharing her extensive knowledge through a new venture: an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews.

It's make easy for you to find the information you need quickly. Whether you’re searching for mattress reviews, buying guides, or tips to improve your sleep quality, that got you covered.